The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) have both created globally accepted approaches to handling the information security of an organisation.
When an organisation wants to improve their approach to information security they are met with a common crossroad in which they choose to either adopt the NIST Framework or ISO 27001 or on some occasions both.
So far we have looked at understanding the NIST Framework, its core functions, the key NIST framework benefits, and how best to implement it into your organisation.
This article hopes to clear up the differences between the two frameworks so that your organisation can make an educated decision on which approach to information security is right for you.
Key differences: NIST Framework vs. ISO 27001
| NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF 2.0) | ISO 27001 (ISO/IEC 27001:2022) |
|---|---|
| First published in 2014 to help US critical infrastructure organisations better manage their cyber risk. Version 2.0 (February 2024) is designed for any organisation, regardless of its size, sector or maturity. | ISO 27001 is an internationally recognised method of creating and managing an Information Security Management System (ISMS). |
| Consists of a Core of cybersecurity outcomes - 6 functions, 22 categories & 106 subcategories. | Consists of an Annex A that has 93 controls in four themes (organisational, people, physical and technological). The 2013 edition had 14 control domains, with 114 total controls. |
| Made up of three main components: the CSF Core, Organizational Profiles & Tiers. Profiles describe the outcomes you currently achieve and the ones you are targeting; Tiers describe the rigour of your cybersecurity risk governance and management. | Utilises a risk-based management approach: the organisation assesses its information security risks and selects controls to treat them, recording them in a Statement of Applicability. |
| Has voluntary self-assessment and self-compliance. There is no official NIST CSF certification. | Relies on independent audit by certification bodies. Organisations will get a certification on successful completion. |
| Uses six main functions (Govern, Identify, Protect, Detect, Respond and Recover) to customise cybersecurity outcomes. It does not prescribe how outcomes should be achieved. | Clauses 4 to 10 set out the requirements that guide an organisation through its Information Security Management System. |
So which to choose, NIST or ISO?
At the end of the day, which framework best suits your business is entirely dependent on the needs of your business and what it wants to achieve, for example Company X is looking to eventually earn ISO 27001 certification, then ISO 27001 is the obvious choice for Company X.
On the other hand another important consideration an organisation should be taking when deciding between the two, is considering what the current level of maturity your organisation’s cyber security is at and its overall risk preparation.
For example, Company Y has never considered its cyber security in the past and is trying to build a risk management program for the first time. The NIST Framework can help the company describe its current cybersecurity posture and the outcomes it is targeting, then prioritise the gaps it needs to address. NIST also publishes Quick-Start Guides and informative references that point to practices and controls for achieving each outcome. This makes the NIST Framework a good starting point for Company Y, as it may progress through the critical areas needed to reach compliance and focus on the specifics required for each stage.
A common misunderstanding is that companies have to pick one or the other and stick with it, or that one is better than the other. In fact, both frameworks can be applied to a single organisation due to their synergy and can greatly increase its data security, risk assessments and security programs. In Australia, the Critical Infrastructure Risk Management Program (CIRMP) Rules list both AS ISO/IEC 27001 and the NIST Cybersecurity Framework among the cyber security frameworks that responsible entities can comply with, and many organisations also use ASD’s Essential Eight alongside either one.
In conclusion, it is important for your organisation to understand where it is at, analysing industry standards and making a list of your goals and priorities can help you make an informed decision on which framework to choose. With ISO 27001 and the NIST Framework your organisation has the advantage that several key areas of improvement overlap between both. Plus, they are both superbly designed and established methods of improving your overall information security to a high standard.
Looking for some professional guidance to make the choice between NIST or ISO 27001? Book a free consultation with one of our experts, and we can assist in making the right choice for your business.
Frequently asked questions
Can an organisation be certified against the NIST Cybersecurity Framework?
No. NIST does not certify organisations against the Cybersecurity Framework, and there is no official NIST CSF certificate. Organisations assess themselves or engage an independent assessor to measure their current and target outcomes against the framework. If you need a certificate to show customers or tenders, ISO 27001 is the option that offers formal third-party certification.
Is the NIST Cybersecurity Framework only for US organisations?
No. Although NIST is a US government agency, the CSF’s taxonomy is not country-specific, and earlier versions were used by governments and organisations both inside and outside the United States. CSF 2.0 is written for any organisation, regardless of size, sector or maturity, and Australia’s CIRMP Rules name it among the frameworks critical infrastructure entities can use.
What is a NIST CSF Organizational Profile?
An Organizational Profile describes your cybersecurity posture in terms of the CSF Core outcomes. A Current Profile covers the outcomes you are achieving now, and a Target Profile covers the outcomes you have selected and prioritised to reach your goals. Comparing the two shows the gaps to close and helps you build an action plan.
What are the NIST CSF Tiers?
The CSF Tiers describe how rigorous an organisation’s cybersecurity risk governance and management practices are. There are four: Partial (Tier 1), Risk Informed (Tier 2), Repeatable (Tier 3) and Adaptive (Tier 4). They are not a maturity score to chase for its own sake; organisations choose the Tier that suits their risk and goals.
Does ISO 27001 certification mean you meet the NIST Cybersecurity Framework?
Not automatically. The two overlap in many areas, such as risk assessment, access control, incident management and supplier security, so an ISO 27001 ISMS gives you a strong head start. However, they are structured differently, so you would still need to map your controls against the CSF’s outcomes, including those in the newer Govern function, to confirm any gaps.
